Cold email follow-up reply rates, step by step, from 1.2M recipients

By , co-founder of Sales.co. Published October 25, 2026, updated November 16, 2026.

Updated November 16, 2026 at 5:28 AM ET · Data through November 1, 2026 (the newest 14 days are left out so replies can arrive) · 1,177,011 recipients and 2,033,956 sent emails from 58 sending workspaces · generated from Sales.co's sending data

Send at least two follow-ups, three emails in all. Across 1,177,011 people Sales.co cold emailed from Oct 6, 2025 to Nov 1, 2026, the second email got 0.47% human replies per recipient against 0.50% for the first, and the third still got 0.38%. The second and third emails each drew most of the first email's rate. Only 29% of recipients got a second email in the window, so follow-ups produced 26.3% of all replies.

What this page adds: the reply rate of each email in a sequence, counted per person who got it before they had replied. It comes from one company's own sending: 1,177,011 recipients and 7,977 human replies, each reply credited to the email it answered. The page is generated from the data file, so the dates above are the dates of the numbers.

Quick answers · By step · Timing · Method · FAQ

Quick answers

How many follow-up emails should a cold email sequence have?
At least two, so three emails in all. In Sales.co's data the second email got 95% of the first email's human reply rate per recipient (0.47% vs 0.50%) and the third got 75% (0.38%, 286 replies). With the largest sender removed those are 102% and 69%. Past the third email the data thins out: 157 and 29 replies at steps four and five, with one sender making up to 44% of those emails. Treat a fourth email and later as a test.
What reply rate does a follow-up email get?
0.47% of recipients replied to the second email (1,600 of 338,506), counting only people who had not replied yet, and 0.14% replied with interest. The first email got 0.50% and 0.15%.
What share of cold email replies come from follow-ups?
26.3% of human replies and 25.7% of interested replies answered a follow-up; 73.7% answered the first email. The share is low mostly because few recipients got a follow-up: 29% got a second email and 6.5% a third. Per person who got one, the second email drew 95% of the first email's reply rate.
How long should you wait before sending a follow-up?
One to two weeks did best in this data. Second emails sent 8-14 days after the first got 0.66% human and 0.266% interested replies per recipient (51,592 recipients), against 0.35% to 0.47% human and at most 0.119% interested for the other gaps. Each campaign picked its own gap, so read this as what happened, and test the gap on your own list.
Do interested replies fall off faster than replies overall?
Not through the third email: its interested rate (0.110%, 84 replies) was 75% of the first email's (0.147%), close to the 75% for all human replies. After that it drops further: the fourth and fifth emails got 0.085% and 0.083% interested (34 and 7 replies, so read those as direction only).
Is the first cold email the most important one?
It reaches everyone, so it brings most replies: 73.7% here. Per person who received it, though, the second email did almost as well (95% of the first email's rate). Here 1,600 people who had not answered the first email replied to the second.

Reply rate by step in the sequence

Each rate below is the share of people who got that email, and had not replied before it, who replied to it. The first email got 0.50%. The second got 0.47%, 95% of that, and the third 0.38%, 75%. With the largest sender removed the pattern holds: 0.46%, 0.47% and 0.32% (102% and 69% of the first). What shrinks fast is the audience: 1,177,011 people got a first email, 338,506 a second (29%) and 76,190 a third (6.5%).

Reply rate per recipient by email step in a cold email sequence Bars for steps 1 to 5. Human reply rate per recipient: step 1 0.50%, step 2 0.47%, step 3 0.38%, step 4 0.39%, step 5 0.34%. Interested rate: step 1 0.147%, step 2 0.137%, step 3 0.110%, step 4 0.085%, step 5 0.083%. 1,177,011 recipients, Oct 6, 2025 to Nov 1, 2026. Replies per recipient, by step in the sequence 0.0% 0.1% 0.2% 0.3% 0.4% 0.5% 0.6% Step 1: 0.50% human (5,878 of 1,177,011) 0.50 Step 1: 0.147% interested (1,726) 0.15 Email 1 1.2M got it Step 2: 0.47% human (1,600 of 338,506) 0.47 Step 2: 0.137% interested (464) 0.14 Email 2 339K got it Step 3: 0.38% human (286 of 76,190) 0.38 Step 3: 0.110% interested (84) 0.11 Email 3 76K got it Step 4: 0.39% human (157 of 39,796) 0.39 Step 4: 0.085% interested (34) 0.09 Email 4 40K got it Step 5: 0.34% human (29 of 8,455) 0.34 Step 5: 0.083% interested (7) 0.08 Email 5 8K got it
Black: human replies per recipient. Gray: interested replies per recipient. n = 1,177,011 recipients, Oct 6, 2025 to Nov 1, 2026. Source: Sales.co sending data.
EmailRecipientsHuman repliesHuman reply rateInterested rateShare of all repliesHuman rate, largest sender removed
first email1,177,0115,8780.50%0.147%73.7%0.46%
second email (follow-up 1)338,5061,6000.47%0.137%20.1%0.47%
third email (follow-up 2)76,1902860.38%0.110% (84)3.6%0.32%
fourth email (follow-up 3)39,7961570.39%0.085% (34)2%0.32% (75)
fifth email (follow-up 4)8,455290.34%0.083% (7)0.4%0.32% (15)
sixth or later email (follow-up 5+)5,37627not shownnot shown0.3%0.43% (12)

Rates resting on fewer than 100 replies show the count in brackets. "Not shown": fewer than 2,000 recipients at that step, or one sending workspace sent more than 45% of those emails. Steps four and five rest on 157 and 29 human replies, and one sender sent 41% and 44% of those emails, so read them as direction only. Source: Sales.co sending data, October 6, 2025 to November 1, 2026.

Why "most replies come from the first email" misleads: it is true here too (73.7% of replies). The figure mostly reflects how few people got a follow-up: per email received, the second email did 95% as well as the first.

How long to wait before the first follow-up

Second emails sent 8-14 days after the first got the highest reply rates in this data: 0.66% human (342 replies from 51,592 recipients) and 0.266% interested (137). The other gaps got 0.35% to 0.47% human and at most 0.119% interested. Without the largest sender, 8-14 days got 0.67% human and 0.265% interested, against at most 0.43% and 0.102%. After 1-2 days, 0.35% replied (13 replies, 0 interested, from 3,698 recipients), too few to rank that gap. Most second emails here went out 15+ days later (77%), so the shorter gaps rest on fewer recipients. Each campaign chose its own gap, so the table shows what happened at each gap; it cannot show what changing yours will do.

Days after email 1Recipients of email 2Human repliesHuman reply rateInterested rateHuman rate, largest sender removed
1-2 days3,698130.35%0.000% (0)0.36% (13)
3-4 days7,381320.43%0.068% (5)0.41% (26)
5-7 days15,855750.47%0.082% (13)0.41% (55)
8-14 days51,5923420.66%0.266%0.67%
15+ days259,9781,1380.44%0.119%0.43%

Days are whole days between the first and second email to the same person. The gap before the third email is left out: 4 of its 5 groups rest on fewer than 50 replies.

What to do with this

Write the sequence as at least three emails. For the second email, one to two weeks after the first did best here; if you follow up sooner, test that gap on part of your list. Interested replies fall with each later email (0.147% on the first, 0.110% by the third on 84 replies), so judge a fourth or fifth email by the interested replies it brings. For wording, see the follow-up email templates and how to follow up a cold email; to check a follow-up for spam words, use the email spam checker. To see what a reply rate means for meetings at your volume, use the lead generation calculator.

To see what each extra email should bring on your own list size, use the free cold email follow-up planner, built on the same data.

If you would rather have someone run the sequences, Sales.co runs done-for-you cold email from $2,000 a month for up to 10,000 emails, month-to-month. See pricing.

Method

Cite this: Sales.co, "Cold email follow-up reply rates, step by step", https://sales.co/research/cold-email-follow-up-reply-rates, data through November 1, 2026.

Where to go next

Best time to send cold email · 11 cold email rules from 1.1M emails · cold email statistics · follow-up email templates · cold email subject line grader · all Sales.co research

Sources

SALES.CO PRICING

FAQ

How many follow-up emails should a cold email sequence have?

At least two, so three emails in all. In Sales.co's data the second email got 95% of the first email's human reply rate per recipient (0.47% vs 0.50%) and the third got 75% (0.38%, 286 replies). With the largest sender removed those are 102% and 69%. Past the third email the data thins out: 157 and 29 replies at steps four and five, with one sender making up to 44% of those emails. Treat a fourth email and later as a test.

What reply rate does a follow-up email get?

0.47% of recipients replied to the second email (1,600 of 338,506), counting only people who had not replied yet, and 0.14% replied with interest. The first email got 0.50% and 0.15%.

What share of cold email replies come from follow-ups?

26.3% of human replies and 25.7% of interested replies answered a follow-up; 73.7% answered the first email. The share is low mostly because few recipients got a follow-up: 29% got a second email and 6.5% a third. Per person who got one, the second email drew 95% of the first email's reply rate.

How long should you wait before sending a follow-up?

One to two weeks did best in this data. Second emails sent 8-14 days after the first got 0.66% human and 0.266% interested replies per recipient (51,592 recipients), against 0.35% to 0.47% human and at most 0.119% interested for the other gaps. Each campaign picked its own gap, so read this as what happened, and test the gap on your own list.

Do interested replies fall off faster than replies overall?

Not through the third email: its interested rate (0.110%, 84 replies) was 75% of the first email's (0.147%), close to the 75% for all human replies. After that it drops further: the fourth and fifth emails got 0.085% and 0.083% interested (34 and 7 replies, so read those as direction only).

Is the first cold email the most important one?

It reaches everyone, so it brings most replies: 73.7% here. Per person who received it, though, the second email did almost as well (95% of the first email's rate). Here 1,600 people who had not answered the first email replied to the second.